Sunday, September 06, 2009

The Empire Strikes Back

As I predicted some time ago, this "health care reform" was indeed perceived as a substantial threat to capitalist forces ( hence the irrational zeal of the shock troops) and though these forces are themselves far from united as to how to proceed, it is obvious that those most concerned with preserving the ideological imperative have prevailed for now. They have decided to kill even this moderate attempt to align ourselves with the rest of the modern western nations, so fervently do they worship at the Temple of Profit. So no, we will not see any substantial gains for the working class in the short run, but a fissure has been opened and a possible Achilles Heel identified. This slight wound, the mere questioning of the legitimacy of profit, is not trivial. The words capitalism and socialism, taboo for decades, have actually entered mainstream discussion, they are seen on signs at rallys and in articles in newspapers and magazines. The Left-Left should be organizing to take advantage of the rare ( and brief) crack in the spectacular narrative.

Witness the stunned dismay of "centrists", moderates, progressives, etc... at the irrational counter-attack against even the "public option". These are the folks most heavily invested in the illusion that there is a "civil discourse" around which our "liberal democracy" is built and include much of the business class that got Obama elected. They depend on the Spectacle and hoped to continue the charade of a "nuetral media" and a "nuetral state" and a "representative government" but they see the veil slipping away to reveal the blatant ideological bias of all these so-called -constitutional institutions. Each "moderate" being asked to justify the profits of the insurance industry is slipping in the muck of contradiction and hypocricy, each sociologist brought on to explain the anger, outrage and frustration stumbles and stammers trying to explain the difference between self-interest and greed, individualism and alienation, rational fear and zenophobic paranoia.Even John Stewart has trouble defending such a corrupt, capitalist government.

This presents amazing opportunities for left radicals and anti-capitalists of all stripes to give a clear, articulate analysis of the historical moment to a understandably confused and frightened public ( workers, managers, coordinators, unemployed) . Only when viewed on a structural level can the dissapointment of liberals and the fear of conservatives be addressed logically and clearly. When someone asks you if you trust "the State" to run the healthcare system you can answer NOT THE CAPITALIST STATE. If someone asks you how you plan to pay for the stimulus and the bailouts you can say WE CAN'T BECAUSE CAPITALISM DOESN'T WORK. If a "progressive" tells you he/she is dissapointed in Obamas Afghanistan policy you can tell him OBAMA IS A CAPITALIST AND THE WAR ON TERROR IS AN IMPERIALIST WAR. We explain that FOX, CNN and NPR are all capitalist media, we explain that all political parties are capitalist parties and all the debt, war, repression, recession, fear and distrust spring from the same Spectacular source.

10 Comments:

At 1:21 AM, Blogger Frank Partisan said...

I disagree with your approach. I think you should present a positive alternative.

Can't pay for universal healthcare? Nationalize the hospitals under workers control.

Disappointed in how Obama is running the war? Troops and mercenaries out now. How can they withdraw? In boats and planes.

How do we pay for bailouts? Open up the books of these companies.

My main point is that you should link the sentiment to concrete demands.

Except at our blogs, there is not going to be much talking to that reactionary layer.

How much dialog can there be when Jonah Goldberg writes a book, claiming amongst other things that the French Revolution was fascist!

 
At 5:11 AM, Blogger sandykrolick, ph.d., editor FIBP said...

I would suggest a Rousseauean approach. This may hurt so bear with me!

The government of the USA was established through enactment of a contract embodied in the Declaration of Independence and the Consitution. This contract was established to insure that each citizen of the State has the right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Under those terms, it is the responsibility of the State to see that each individual has that opportunity. Such assurance demands that each individual has non-punative access to basic healthcare if and when necessary in order to safeguard his or her rights to LIFE, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.

The right to healthcare coverage is implicit in our founding documents; and while it may not square with the capitalistic model of economic exchange we have adopted; it squares with the human rights doctrines embebded in our founding!

 
At 7:28 AM, Blogger Ducky's here said...

Well trout it's going to get worse this week unless we catch lightning in a bottle. A case is coming up in front of the Supreme Court that will cripple any attempts at campaign reform.

The status of the corporation as "person" (and the right screams about 'activist' rulings) is going to be extended further in the arena of media and contributions.

Afghanistan? Just what are we trying to accomplish? Ask him and if he can't answer then get the hell out. It's a smart bet because the likelihood of any reasonable answer that doesn't involve "extending freedom and democracy" is unlikely.

Any populist progress will be stifled by the corporate control of media. Whomever controls the images these days controls the culture. We need guerrilla artists everywhere.

 
At 7:56 AM, Blogger Ducky's here said...

According to The New York Times, loyalists to Afghanistan's incumbent President Hamid Karzai stuffed ballot boxes at hundreds of fake polling sites.

The fake sites, as many as 800, existed only on paper, said a senior Western diplomat in Afghanistan, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the political delicacy of the vote...

"We think that about 15 percent of the polling sites never opened on Election Day," the senior Western diplomat said. "But they still managed to report thousands of ballots for Karzai."

---------------

Interesting news clip. Maybe SCOTUS can certify the election.

What is the mission there exactly?

 
At 6:36 PM, Blogger Frank Partisan said...

I'm close to closing my blog. There is no dialoging with the right.

There was some good days talking to Sonia and CB. Now its all vulgar.

 
At 7:12 AM, Blogger troutsky said...

You are of course correct Ren about a positive program and these are all good proposals. I just think this opening for de-construction is so ripe and the arguments so obvious...still my "progressive" friends think it's a failure in"framing" the issues! ( the scare quotes are surrogates for critical analysis, I know, but what does it mean when EVERY ideological position has scare quotes?)

By the way, I understand the frustration with blog and lack of serious dialogue. (Sonia and CB were serious?) I expected more myself. What about reaching out and trying to find a new network?

kultur, I think this is a serious approach. It is after all democracy which is (and always has been) at stake. The tension with liberty will always exist but some equilibrium is possible, isn't it? Anarcho-capitalists have had their way and look what it has wrought!

Ducky, Bill Moyers interviewed lawyers for the plaintiff and defence last week. Now that Money is Speech the Richest are the Loudest. And the Loudest always wins.
Our Supreme Court should have a golf tournament with the Honduran Supreme Court! How sublimely supreme.

 
At 9:42 AM, Blogger Graeme said...

Great post and discussion! I especially like the last paragraph.

 
At 11:29 PM, Blogger Frank Partisan said...

There are less Obama t-shirts being worn.

 
At 6:23 AM, Blogger sandykrolick, ph.d., editor FIBP said...

Well now; there you have it trotsky... real capitalism... and a real marketing opportunity with Audrey... better grab it!!

 
At 11:38 AM, Blogger Ducky's here said...

Well troutsky, this upcoming court case is potentially monumental. If they take an activist position that opens the corporate spigot for any and all electioneering then they have in fact destroyed the legitimacy of the court.

Honduras indeed.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home