Monday, February 06, 2012

Why Are Corporations Bad? part 5

You cannot spit without hitting some article blaming corporations for the mess the world is in. According to this meme "They" rape and pillage at will, they are the 1% who hog everything, they are the elite who control everything and THEY must be stopped before it is too late. To many, "they" are synonymous with Wall Street and the opposite of Main Street. This seems to be the thing that finally unites the left, from Occupy to Yes magazine!

But I'm thinking this is yet another misdirection. By focusing on one organizational strategy of capital rather than the logic of capitalism itself, you risk a myopic view leading to a myopic "solution".I'm no fan of corporations,mind you, but what is it exactly that is so objectionable to so many? The hierarchical structure? The sheer size of the biggies? Their disproportional influence over the "political" process? What is a corporation really?

A corporation is a group authorized to act as a single entity. The business my mechanic buddy owns is incorporated so that his liability is limited (he won't lose his house if his employee does something stupid). He is on Main Street. So it must be the organizational model. But no, he allows his two employees equal decision making power.Google feeds it's employees catered lunches and pays really good. I know a farmer with ten seasonal employees who exploits the shit out his help. So it must be the size factor, when they get too big they can demand things or buy people. As monopolies they can corner markets. But how big is too big? (can we pinpoint some number?) And what would keep them from splitting up but still coordinating? What if they formed trade organizations? What if they met in Switzerland and made plans?

The point here is that the local Main Street store can be twice as ruthless as Costco. And their union, the Chamber of Commerce, is viciously anti-worker. And a small, local bank can screw you just as effectively as a big one. Their board of directors is no more transparent than Goldman Sachs and the CEO might be a racist reactionary way worse than Blankfien.

So if people want to spend all their energy de-corporatizing capitalism (pit bull) to make it smaller and gentler and kinder (like a puppy?) they will find themselves on the ground having their throats ripped out by a pack of chows.

7 Comments:

At 6:26 PM, Blogger SecondComingOfBast said...

As opposed to having yourself torn limb from limb and eaten alive by "the people".

 
At 8:50 AM, Blogger troutsky said...

Patrick: I'm pretty sure I just wrote "people" but I understand your fear of too much unity, too much group think, that Violent Jacobin imaginary.

And yet I'm sure you imagine yourself a rebel, free thinker.Everyone does, even those who accept the most dominant narratives, say, democratic capitalism.We are all Thomas Paine somwhow.

 
At 9:22 AM, Blogger SecondComingOfBast said...

Sure, everybody's got a bit of the rebel in them. That's precisely what government tries to squash, even when they seem to be trying to channel that energy, maybe especially then. That's why they are not to be trusted, no matter what "ideology" they try to cloak themselves with. That holds just as true for these big government conservatives who wrap themselves in cloaks of religion and patriotism.

The people should always distrust government, and government should always view the people with fear. When they don't, that's when they start thinking they can fuck us.

 
At 2:26 PM, Blogger Ducky's here said...

Actually, it's what advertising tries to quash. The image of the rebel is encouraged while consumerism promotes conformity.

As long as we're comfortable we think we're free.

 
At 6:31 PM, Blogger SecondComingOfBast said...

Bullshit Ducky.

 
At 1:51 AM, Blogger beakerkin said...

Lets see people emigrate from
Venezuela, Cuba and communist messes but not from Walmart. The fact remains that nothing but excuses prevents Troutsky from self deportation to join Hugo. He merely is a bull shit Bolshevik who fails reality 1001

 
At 1:45 AM, Anonymous DRS said...

Excellent article Patrick. I just hope Troutsky is not directly relating all large corporations to government as most corporations are privately held and most of those corporations shareholders are made up of citizens who have absolutely nothing to do with government.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home