Ray of Hope
I went to one last Holiday party last night and after an acquaintance asked about my year I ended up with a great new Wobblie. Step by step, as the song goes.Turns out there are people out there yearning for an alternative to politics-as-usual, looking to connect.This was my Christmas present!
Che Bob pointed me to an interesting manifesto of sorts by a group known as the Tarnac 9. In the style of Guy Debord it lays out a cultural/political critique full of irony: "Here lies the present paradox: work has totally triumphed over other ways of existing at the very moment when workers have become superfluous." Here they refer to Western Europe which like the U.S. has exported work to cheaper realms but still worships it's moral curative power.
In the "7th circle" called "We are building a civilized space" there are many ideas similar to those kulturcritic presents in his book The Recovery of Ecstacy.They don't try to identify a "departure point" as such but it is a piercing critique of our most basic "civilizing" structures and myths.
There is an interesting unpacking of the new Green Economy/Great Turning sort of progressivism": "The petite bourgeois is quick to embrace the new fad of 'degrowth'" which "preserves the economic as morality". "Consume and produce less. Become joyously frugal.Eat Organic, ride your bike,stop smoking,and pay close attention to the products that you buy." "Don't use up our natural capital." "Avoid a social crisis that would threaten humanism and democracy." Simply put: become economical. This new 'bioeconomy' cannot be established without screening subjects and zones singled out for transformation. "The chaos that we hear about will either provide the opportunity for this screening or for our victory over this odious project."
It would be easy to argue that Copenhagen demonstrated precisely this "screening" process, which is nothing new I suppose, but compliments the "dispossession" David Harvey talks about. Some of what they write appears contradictory, such as this warning to "don't become an organization or milieu" followed a paragraph later by the injunction to "organize...and spread this necessary disposition towards fraud." I find this poorly defined boundary fairly often with "autonomistas". The forms of resistance that are advocated in the text such as fraud and theft against "the system" is different than Freeganism. The workers will simply be taxed more to pay for their leisure.Also, the Tarnac 9 advocacy for "self-dependence" sounds a great deal like what I heard at Celebrating Conservatism, survival kits and skill sets from the frontier days.
My real question is, what did the "fires of 2005" really accomplish? This growing unrest can be linked to movements in Greece and perhaps Mexico,anywhere else? What autonomous movements exist in Europe? Are they growing? Where would one look?

11 Comments:
The fires of 2005?
Again, I refer you to The Coming Insurrection, which I previously forwarded to you. As you can see, it has also influenced the Tarnac 9
http://tarnac9.wordpress.com/texts/the-coming-insurrection/
A leftist radical in Minneapolis, produced a documentary called No Impact Man. It's about a family who tried for a year to make no carbon footprint. That is not what socialism is about. If anything its about abundance. Progress is about conquering nature.
Holiday Greetings.
That is not what socialism is about. If anything its about abundance. Progress is about conquering nature.
Wow - I'd say that Renegade and Kultur have a long way to go to see eye to eye!
Thanks for the link to Tarnac 9 text. I love that stuff.
What a load of BS.
The Green movement is merely the latest subterfuge that Bolshevik works use to cloak their lust for power and death.
We do not need power mad lunatics dictating consumer choice. If you want to eat organic go ahead, but get your stinking Marxist paws off my produce. People who are apologists for a system that produces shortages of produce should not lecture anyone about choices.
You can find fresh produce anywhere in any poor section of America. Would any of the death cultists claim that Chinese, North Koreans, Soviet, Cubans and Venezuelans are all telling identical lies?
The American people should decide how to balance growth vs the environment. In all cases this should be done by locals.
kultur, I had completely forgotten that you first alerted me to it.I had only glanced at it and dismissed it but on further examination it's a uniquely modern analysis.
Ren: I agree. If people want to live in caves, more power to em. Freedom from markets means sustainable plenty for all.Are you using "progress" as a pejorative?
Lichanos, It is a great style I wish I could emulate.
Beak; I wish more Greens were anti-capitalist. As for decision making, I agree. I'm not as sure about the availability of healthy food for poor people. Cost is a factor.
This comment has been removed by the author.
Trout, my leftist bent tends to originate more in Robert Owen and the original socialists than it does in Marx. Despite Beak's attempts to correct my mental infirmities I do accept a lot of Marx's critique of capitalism but I believe it was Owen who identified the disruption to community represented by capitalism.
In other words, folks like Beak who rail against the destruction of basic values also champion an economic system which does much of the damage.
The Greens are too comfortable to question the capitalist paradigm and play into their hands by promoting change that can be effective at the individual level.
I think those individual activities are useful but they aren't going to resolve the issue of the destruction of community.
Beak for your lesson I would like you to pick a couple of Godard's analyses of consumerism from the 60's and we can discuss them. That would be fun.
I suggest "Two or Three Things I Know About Her" and "Band of Outsiders". Let me know when you're ready.
Troutsky
Unlike you I do venture into the poorest sections of the city. One can find fresh produce in seconds in the worst areas. Oddly, it is harder for a person living in a rural area.Then again people like yourself piss on poor rural folks by advocating gas taxes that adversely impact poor
rural workers.
Unlike Marxist thugs, it is not the duty of government to dictate
what food citizens should eat. The job of government is to ensure the food is tested and safe.
What sort of Greens are you talking about. Obviously, the act of Prof. Joel Koevell is convincing only to those who are lobotomized. Communists have infiltrated the Green movement to such an extent they are little more than a joke.
Duncy
Who died and left you in charge of consumer choice. Sorry, but your fealty to a power mad lazy bum failed philosopher renders your opinion comedic. Sorry, but the American people do not want or need a nanny state run by stealth Marxists.
The Greens in the US, are a mess. Every state party is different, as to how the party operates. Some take part in electoral politics, others don't. Some even support Democrats. In Europe they have been the biggest cutters of social services.
Ducky: Robert Owen is called a utopian socialist, for a reason. You can't have islands of socialism, in a sea of capitalism. Later in his life, he acknowledged the need for class struggle. See Engels on Owen.
Troutsky:Are you using "progress" as a pejorative? I don't think so.
Thanks ren, a useful citing. However, the real kudos go to Beak for pointing out that Owen was a lazy bum.
The Greens in Minnesota, endorsed the same mayoral candidate as the Republicans.
Post a Comment
<< Home